Almost every day I take our two dogs, Sierra and Leone, out for a walk in our neighborhood in Lebanon, NH. It used to be that I'd find some music on Pandora that would help me relax or focus or whatever I needed at the time but these days I just walk sans earbuds and think.
These days with President Obama reelected there are lots of things to think about. He has a fresh outlook on how the world works that was unfortunately obscured by having to deal with a Republican Party unwilling to consider non-dogmatic approaches - by which I mean that he seems to get that our lives are surrounded by and enmeshed in all kinds of systems. So when he proposed changes in, say, healthcare, he was able to articulate a vision of how the reduction in the cost of healthcare, the improvement in the quality of healthcare and improvements in the economy are all connected, though again the message definitely got garbled by his willingness to consider other means of obtaining the same goal. Having said that, it is still so easy for some to focus on single issues because they don't have to think thoughts about how that issue may be affected by or may affect other issues. People are sometimes so desperate for a single answer to their problems that they just want to hide everything else from their view. Granted, healthcare is an extremely complex and complicated system of systems and it can be difficult to see how to make headway.
This reminds me of how I was taught to solve problems in my physics and engineering training: since the real world is horrendously complicated, take away the parts that you deem to be either irrelevant or have a negligible effect on the solution to the problem. Classic reductionism. And sometimes in order to understand how a system of interacting components works you need to be very reductive. But you can't forgo the next step of synthesizing your new knowledge about the component all by itself with how you observe it to behave in the presence of other components. If you don't synthesize, you arrive at a solution that ignores those important interactions and you become blind to aspects of the your that don't fit. Some people become so focused on a particular approach in science that they fail to see when throwing away the parts of the system that don't fit their solution causes their "solution" to no longer be of any real value. New solutions arise out of new frameworks and approaches that allow for these other parts of the system.
There are groups of people, for instance, that seem to believe that if we just had a flat tax that would be the answer to our problems. There are others, the 912-ers, who fervently believe that if you just follow the 9 principles and the 12 Values everything will be solved. These are generally very black and white perspectives on the world. Either you are with me or you are with "them". It seems that there is this deep and desperate desire to find the One Solution and never anymore have to think or make decisions, except about whether what one is doing is being done according to the One Solution or not.
Yet in my experience there has not so far been a "One Solution" that has been able to answer all questions in a way that makes sense perfectly for all time.
Showing posts with label systems thinking. Show all posts
Showing posts with label systems thinking. Show all posts
Wednesday, December 5, 2012
Sunday, August 9, 2009
Healthcare Reform and Linear Thinking
I've been listening to and reading responses from conservative Republicans to the Obama Administration's effort to reform the way health care is being performed and paid for in this country. I've frankly been astonished at the level of vitriol being issued by talking heads and bloggers on the right. You would think that Obama was one of the four horsemen of the Apocalypse and that as a result of health care reform we would all be forced to wait for hours in order to get substandard health care. Oh, wait, we already have that.
So, no it's that we will have some bureaucrat in Washington, DC deciding on whether or not we can get care. Oh, wait, we already have that...except my bureaucrat works for Aetna; but his or her role is the same: deciding on whether the care I get is appropriate or not.
So, no, it's that health care will become extraordinarily expensive if we make changes we will all be paying dearly just so everyone can get covered. Oh, wait, we already have that! Hospitals already have to charge insurance companies a premium over their actual cost since a certain percentage of their patients have no insurance or their insurance has been maxed out and so we do pay for the uninsured and under-insured. Plus a public hospital is legally bound to provide care to all, no matter if they can pay or not, so guess whose taxes pay for that?
There is a system that has grown around the payment for health care in this country that has constantly been pushed to shift costs from one group to another. As a result, in this country we have very little relationship between how much care costs and our health, as demonstrated in the Dartmouth Atlas project. So paying more does not give better care! How more non-linear can one get?
So how can we solve the issues surrounding health care reform? Not through the kind of dogma-driven arguments we have been seeing. Dogma has a very linear view of the world: there is my way (the right way) and any other way (the disastrously wrong way). Dogma is driven by belief systems not by data - just think of Galileo and the moons around Jupiter that could not exist in the Catholic Church's view of the world. Dogma is not interested in data that does not fit in to an established world-view since that data threatens the very stability of that world view.
Systems thinking relies on the kind of data that is provided by the above-mentioned Dartmouth Atlas project as well as many other Comparative Effectiveness studies. Systems and holarchical thinking value any kind of insight and data that does not fit into established ways of thinking since that is how we come to know more how a particular system works.
So a holarchical/systems view of health care looks at all aspects and contributing factors to one's health - genetics, lifestyle, family dynamics, community, socio-economic factors, environmental effects, access to care, employment, presence or lack of health insurance and one's spiritual life just to name a few - and how a health care system can be constructed to improve all our health. If we agree to put aside dogma and let data speak to us we can start the process of understanding how to move forward.
So, no it's that we will have some bureaucrat in Washington, DC deciding on whether or not we can get care. Oh, wait, we already have that...except my bureaucrat works for Aetna; but his or her role is the same: deciding on whether the care I get is appropriate or not.
So, no, it's that health care will become extraordinarily expensive if we make changes we will all be paying dearly just so everyone can get covered. Oh, wait, we already have that! Hospitals already have to charge insurance companies a premium over their actual cost since a certain percentage of their patients have no insurance or their insurance has been maxed out and so we do pay for the uninsured and under-insured. Plus a public hospital is legally bound to provide care to all, no matter if they can pay or not, so guess whose taxes pay for that?
There is a system that has grown around the payment for health care in this country that has constantly been pushed to shift costs from one group to another. As a result, in this country we have very little relationship between how much care costs and our health, as demonstrated in the Dartmouth Atlas project. So paying more does not give better care! How more non-linear can one get?
So how can we solve the issues surrounding health care reform? Not through the kind of dogma-driven arguments we have been seeing. Dogma has a very linear view of the world: there is my way (the right way) and any other way (the disastrously wrong way). Dogma is driven by belief systems not by data - just think of Galileo and the moons around Jupiter that could not exist in the Catholic Church's view of the world. Dogma is not interested in data that does not fit in to an established world-view since that data threatens the very stability of that world view.
Systems thinking relies on the kind of data that is provided by the above-mentioned Dartmouth Atlas project as well as many other Comparative Effectiveness studies. Systems and holarchical thinking value any kind of insight and data that does not fit into established ways of thinking since that is how we come to know more how a particular system works.
So a holarchical/systems view of health care looks at all aspects and contributing factors to one's health - genetics, lifestyle, family dynamics, community, socio-economic factors, environmental effects, access to care, employment, presence or lack of health insurance and one's spiritual life just to name a few - and how a health care system can be constructed to improve all our health. If we agree to put aside dogma and let data speak to us we can start the process of understanding how to move forward.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)