Wednesday, June 14, 2023

Brené Brown, Shame & Asking for Help

Why don't I just ask for or even accept the offer of help?

Note: 

I wrote this several years ago and I have gotten better at this, but I still need to keep a post-it note above my monitor: 

Tuesday, January 30, 2018

Uncle Charlie, Jingles, and Co-creation

When I was a kid my father used to take my brother and me to go see Uncle Charlie, who was actually a great uncle or some other kind of second or third order relative. I remember very clearly that he had several toasters, and a collection of small appliances. Today we might think that poor Uncle Charlie or Aunt Evangeline was hooked on QVC or some other shopping channel. But back then it was the fruit of Uncle Charlie's jingles. For those of you not yet of a certain age, the term jingle may be a little unfamiliar. From Wikipedia:
A jingle is a short song or tune used in advertising and for other commercial uses. The jingle contains one or more hooks and meaning that explicitly promote the product or service being advertised, usually through the use of one or more advertising slogans. Ad buyers use jingles in radio and television commercials; they can also be used in non-advertising contexts to establish or maintain a brand image.
Here is an example of some jingles played on the radio in the 1950's; Soundcloud has a pretty large selection. Most jingles were composed by professional jingle writers, but contests funded by advertisers were big in the 1950's and 1960's and some of those contests were to elicit jingles from the public. I don't know when my uncle decided to try this out but by the number of duplicate household items in their house, I imagine it had been more than something to wile away his years of retirement. It also appears he was pretty good at this. Some people took this to another level and Evelyn Ryan was able to help support her family through her jingle writing/composing; there was even a book and a movie made about her, so it was really a thing back then.

Yannig Roth's blog has an excellent post about this phenomenon, and he makes the point that using contests to get jingles and recipes from ordinary people was a very early form of what we now call crowdsourcing. (I know, how meta to have a link to Wikipedia's definition of crowdsourcing) Today, crowdsourcing efforts are enabled and amplified by the connectivity of the internet. But I see that there is more to crowdsourcing that Amazon's Mechanical Turks, which focus primarily on distributing microtasks to anyone with an internet connection; this can be a bit of translation or image recognition and this is an example of an act of co-creation, albeit not usually an act where one received recognition for the addition of intellectual property.

At its best co-creation enables and engages the imaginative and innovative energy of its participants. Examples are:

  • Github where those who create in code can collaborate. The community includes companies who use the platform to securely host and manage their code, open source communities such as The Apache Software Foundation, and I also have my own bits and bobs of code.
  • Thingiverse where those who create shapes for 3D printers can share their ideas; many shapes can be downloaded and edited by anyone and then shared again.
  • Lego Ideas where fans can submit their ideas for Lego© sets to be voted on by other Lego fans- and 10,000 "thumbs-up" guarantees that your idea will be reviewed by Lego designers. There are also subject-specific contests where the top 25 votegetters will be assessed by judges and the winner will receive "The opportunity to have your model adapted into an exclusive LEGO Gift with Purchase set".
  • GE’s FirstBuild micro factory, "a kind of crowdsourcing makerspace for people to collaborate with GE to design appliances" (Makezine). 

The last two items in the list above demonstrate how a commercial entity (as big as GE) works to reduce the cost of developing new products by allowing "super users" (and "super fans" in the case of Lego) to provide ideas and feedback before sending a product out for retail "on spec".

So it's a long road from my Uncle Charlie's jingles providing my Aunt Evangeline with far more toasters that could fit into her kitchen to GE and other companies (DeWalt & Price Chopper) providing a platform for customers to go from consumer to co-creator. But the constant is to increase a sense of buy-in to the product or service by engaging people's creativity.

Anyone else out there have an experience with co-creating? Jingle-writing??


Tuesday, December 29, 2015

Multipotentialites - Thank you Emilie Wapnick!

This post is a slightly modified version of a response I gave to a blog post about the difference between ADD and Multipotentiality (see below for more on that).

I was diagnosed with ADD as an adult. The criteria seemed to fit and I had always wondered what was "wrong" with me that I could never seem to settle on any one particular career path.

Some history: Out of college I worked in Silicon Valley in the late 70's and early 80's, moved to construction for the next 13 years, to programming in the mid-90's, and from 2000 on I "settled' on biomedical informatics. At least that discipline had enough dimensions that it kept me pretty much on the same career path.

So in 2004 I had that diagnosis. I started to take Adderall regularly and it did seem to help. I had always been a big coffee drinker so this just seemed like coffee on steroids. However last year I had a big crisis at work where everything seemed to fall apart. Talk about feeling like a total imposter! I had a complete meltdown, something I had not had since I was in high school. After I got a horrible review at work I decided I had to really get coaching for my ADD.

Luckily I went to see a neuropsychologist who wanted to give me a complete neurocognitive assessment before working with me. When she gave me the results she told me that, clinically speaking, I did not have ADD. Rather I was very bright and had multiple aptitudes. This meant that I didn't have anything wrong, I just needed some help in figuring out how to harness and filter all those things I'd like to do.

This was a huge relief for me since it removed the stigma I had placed on myself for most of my adult life. There wasn't anything wrong with me, I just could never be fully engaged by any one thing. Then I came across Emilie Wapnick's TED talk (http://goo.gl/Dc6fzu) on Multipotentialites and it was a revelation that not only was I okay, I was not alone. Here is a definition of the term from Wikipedia:
 “An educational and psychological term referring to a pattern found among intellectually gifted individuals. [Multipotentialites] generally have diverse interests across numerous domains and may be capable of success in many endeavors or professions, they are confronted with unique decisions as a result of these choices.”
Emilie's site, http://www.puttylike.com, is a continuing source of comfort and inspiration.

Since then I've come across something called T-shaped persons (see http://tsummit.org/ for some interesting information). This describes a person who has a particular strength (the upright part of the T) and connects with many other interests or disciplines (the crossbar at the top of the T). I think of myself as more crossbar than upright, but everyone is different. I find that I enjoy being at the crossroads between many disciplines - this is probably why I have lasted as long as I did in my current field. Biomedical Informatics covers a whole lot of territory!

Thursday, May 21, 2015

The Turkey Club Sandwich Experience

Turkey Club Sandwich photo courtesy of http://www.taste.com.au/recipes/14237/classic+turkey+club+sandwich

The other day on my way home from Boston I ordered a Turkey Club at Au Bon Pain at South Station. When I went to pick the sandwich up, I was asked if I had wanted the one without mayonnaise. I was confused and didn’t quite know why. Finally I wondered aloud, “Is a Turkey Club Sandwich without mayonnaise really a Turkey Club?”. No one bothered answering me, which is not surprising since everyone was busy getting ready to get on a train or a bus somewhere. But still it got me thinking about how this sandwich was an example of a system.

Well, I could be wrong about what defines a Turkey Club Sandwich. The Wikipedia entry for Club Sandwich states, 
“A club sandwich, also called a clubhouse sandwich, is a sandwich of toasted bread, sliced poultry, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. It is often cut into quarters or halves and held together by hors d'œuvre sticks [AKA toothpicks]. Modern versions frequently have two layers which are separated by an additional slice of bread.” [emphasis added]
So based on the list of items, it would appear that mayonnaise is indeed critical to the makeup of a club sandwich. But I seemed to have an almost visceral response to the absence of mayo, so what else was going on? 

It turns out that the definition of a system is helpful:
"A system is a set of interacting or interdependent components forming an integrated whole."
So I think it was this concept of the "integrated whole" that unconsciously came to mind when I started wondering about the role of mayonnaise in a Turkey Club Sandwich. And it really does make sense when you apply this idea to other kinds of meals or snacks. Taken alone, each part of a club sandwich tastes good (tomatoes in season and picked ripe are essential here!), but when put together, the whole is really more than the sum of the parts. Each component - bacon, lettuce, turkey, toast and mayo - contributes along multiple dimensions to the overall experience. So I made up this table to help me think this through:

ComponentCrunchinessSaltinessSweetnessUmamiTartness
ToastX
TurkeyXX
TomatoX
LettuceX
MayoXXX
BaconXXX

So based on this admittedly non-technical set of categories I can see that for me, the mayo contributes something missing from all the other ingredients that comes from either the lemon or vinegar added to it. But this still is a bit reductionist for my "taste". For me it is ultimately the combination of all these components with their different attributes all interacting in my mouth at the same time that make up the "Turkey Club Sandwich Experience". It's like the toast, turkey, tomato, lettuce, mayonnaise and bacon are all having a rave party in my mouth!


Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Wolves, Grizzlies, Elk and Berries - an unexpected set of dependencies

I just got through reading the Science Daily version [1] of a journal article, Trophic cascades from wolves to grizzly bears in Yellowstone.[2] The article describes how an unexpected relationship has been discovered between the populations of wolves, elk and grizzly bears through berries. Turns out without wolves around the elk suffered little predation - except for human hunting - and their expanding numbers fed on berries, reducing their availability to the grizzly bear. However, the grizzly really needed that late summer/early fall crop of berries to get them ready for winter, so fewer berries meant fewer grizzlies. Although grizzlies are omnivores and did take their share of elk, this was not enough to sustain their numbers. So with the re-introduction of wolves, the population of elk was naturally reduced, which led to more berries being available, which led to greater numbers of grizzlies surviving their winters. So, very simplistically, the relationship could be represented by a series of statements:

Wolves /\ => Elk \/
Elk \/ => Berries /\
Berries /\ => Grizzlies /\
Therefore,
Wolves /\ => Grizzlies /\

What is really interesting to me is that there has tended to be a certain hysteria that has taken over discussions in the US about re-introducing wolves into local wilderness over the last 40 years or so. The hysteria seems to be driven by anectdotal "evidence" of how wolves are responsible for widespread livestock losses, reductions of game animals such as elk, or deaths of humans and/or their pets. Although the wolf does indeed feed upon both wild prey and domesticated animals, the wolf seems to have been portrayed as an evil and vicious creature in fables and myths as a result of the view centered on our reliance on the sheep, cows and pigs we've raised for sustenance. Even so, the wolf needs to calculate any preference for domesticated livestock over wild prey against fear of humans. If there is a shortage of wild prey (often called "game animals" in the US), then the wolves' hunger will overcome that fear. In Eurasia where there is little wild prey available, wolves are much more likely to attack domesticated livestock than in the US where there are substantial numbers of animals for the wolves to feed on [3][4].


[1] Of bears and berries: Return of wolves aids grizzly bears in Yellowstone
[2] William J. Ripple, Robert L. Beschta, Jennifer K. Fortin, Charles T. Robbins. Trophic cascades from wolves to grizzly bears in Yellowstone. Journal of Animal Ecology, 2013; DOI: 10.1111/1365-2656.12123
[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gray_wolf#Relationships_with_humans
[4] Mech, L. David; Boitani, Luigi (2003). Wolves: Behaviour, Ecology and Conservation. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 0-226-51696-2.

Monday, March 18, 2013

Death and Dying on LinkedIn

Has a friend or colleague who is also a contact on LinkedIn passed away? I recently attempted to follow LinkedIn directions on how to notify them about a friend's death since his profile was still active and he had died over two years ago; it was not easy. The process laid out by LinkedIn did not work - the instructions were wrong/unclear/incomplete and so I had to do this through the Help & Support system with multiple messages back and forth over two weeks. Even then, if I search for my deceased friend, here is the message I get back from the system:


I suppose that technically this is true, but this message has no meaning at all for anyone else who might be searching from my friend. In fact, I would even say that this is cruel and puts LinkedIn in a bad light. I sent a message about this plus asking about an Obituary section to the Help & Support team and this was the response:



Hi Paul,

I'm sorry for the missing part of your inquiry. Currently, the Docusign form is our official notification and process in order to identify and close a deceased member's account. You're unable to view the profile because of it having recently been closed. 

Feedback from members like you provides us with insights that identify the needs of our customers. I sent your message to our research and development team for review and consideration in future developments.

Although every idea cannot be individually responded to or implemented, please know that we do monitor suggestions quite closely for recurring themes. I'd like to invite you to follow us on Twitter http://twitter.com/linkedin or check out the LinkedIn Blog http://blog.linkedin.com for the latest notifications on site improvements. Both options are great ways to stay informed about new releases and exciting work going on behind the scenes here at LinkedIn.

Regards,

Jason
LinkedIn Trust & Safety



Notice that Jason does not address the bizarre nature of the message I received when searching. And apparently the death of members is not seen as a "recurring theme" by support. Unbelievable.

As you know if you have lost anyone, it's hard enough to notify others, but if the process to do the notification is arduous, well that just is unacceptable. I recently went through this process with a family member and I saw how a good funeral home makes the process as smooth as possible. Of course, this is their business, but really it takes people who realize that if their company is built on connections, they must, must, must be able to gracefully honor the unfortunate severing of those connections due to someone's death.

Another LinkedIn member suggested that there be an Obituary section, which I think is a fantastic idea. I'm not an actuary, but with the number of members LinkedIn has, and a recent LinkedIn blog put that number at 58 million, there has to be a non-trivial number who die each year. On Obit section would be a great way of honoring friends and colleagues. It would also be great to have a way of having colleagues notified when someone dies.

However, organizational processes are a reflection of the organizational culture and it looks to me like the culture of LinkedIn is all about growing their community and looking forward to a glorious future. But not so much about looking back or considering the messy & difficult processes involved in death and dying or even just accepting the unpleasant fact of death. It may be that it comes from the energies of the 20 & 30 year olds that make up most of the company's ranks. I never thought much about death when I was that young!

Nevertheless, Facebook has accepted that people will die and they provide a process for "memorializing" or deleting an account upon that member's death:


Memorializing the account:
It is our policy to memorialize the account of a deceased person.
In order to protect the privacy of the deceased person, we cannot provide login information for the account. However, once it has been memorialized, we take measures to secure the account.
If you need to report a timeline to be memorialized, please contact us.
Removing the account:
Verified immediate family members may request the removal of a loved one’s account from the site.

So it's really not so hard to do. I wonder how long it will take LinkedIn to come up with the same? 


Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Thoughts while I'm walking the dogs

Almost every day I take our two dogs, Sierra and Leone, out for a walk in our neighborhood in Lebanon, NH.  It used to be that I'd find some music on Pandora that would help me relax or focus or whatever I needed at the time but these days I just walk sans earbuds and think.

These days with President Obama reelected there are lots of things to think about.  He has a fresh outlook on how the world works that was unfortunately obscured by having to deal with a Republican Party unwilling to consider non-dogmatic approaches - by which I mean that he seems to get that our lives are surrounded by and enmeshed in all kinds of systems.  So when he proposed changes in, say, healthcare, he was  able to articulate a vision of how the reduction in the cost of healthcare, the improvement in the quality of healthcare and improvements in the economy are all connected, though again the message definitely got garbled by his willingness to consider other means of obtaining the same goal. Having said that, it is still so easy for some to focus on single issues because they don't have to think thoughts about how that issue may be affected by or may affect other issues.  People are sometimes so desperate for a single answer to their problems that they just want to hide everything else from their view. Granted, healthcare is an extremely complex and complicated system of systems and it can be difficult to see how to make headway.

This reminds me of how I was taught to solve problems in my physics and engineering training: since the real world is horrendously complicated, take away the parts that you deem to be either irrelevant or have a negligible effect on the solution to the problem.  Classic reductionism.  And sometimes in order to understand how a system of interacting components works you need to be very reductive. But you can't forgo the next step of synthesizing your new knowledge about the component all by itself with how you observe it to behave in the presence of other components. If you don't synthesize, you arrive at a solution that ignores those important interactions and you become blind to aspects of the your that don't fit.  Some people become so focused on a particular approach in science that they fail to see when throwing away the parts of the system that don't fit their solution causes their "solution" to no longer be of any real value. New solutions arise out of new frameworks and approaches that allow for these other parts of the system.

There are groups of people, for instance, that seem to believe that if we just had a flat tax that would be the answer to our problems.  There are others, the 912-ers, who fervently believe that if you just follow the 9 principles and the 12 Values everything will be solved. These are generally very black and white perspectives on the world.  Either you are with me or you are with "them".  It seems that there is this deep and desperate desire to find the One Solution and never anymore have to think or make decisions, except about whether what one is doing is being done according to the One Solution or not.

Yet in my experience there has not so far been a "One Solution" that has been able to answer all questions in a way that makes sense perfectly for all time.

Thursday, September 6, 2012

Why I usually wear my headphones at work...

Someone close by was offering technical support over the phone. After my neighbor listened to the other person for a bit, she replied, "Oh, you're in the wrong universe!" All I could visualize were incorrectly labeled wormholes.

Monday, February 21, 2011

The Stunningly Narrow Definition of Fair Taxation

I ran across this article just yesterday. In it, the Union Leader of Manchester, NH, reported on the perceptions by local New Hampshirites about the fairness of the vehicle fees charged by the state. To be fair, when I first moved from Norwich, Vermont to Lebanon, New Hampshire almost six years ago, it was a shock the first time I had to pay the fee. However, as I looked at how New Hampshire's tax structure was set up it made more sense.

First, there is no income tax at all. Second there is a minimal sales tax; nothing broadly applied for all purchases but instead to meals, hotels, gasoline and liquor. In short, a set of sales taxes designed for the tourist to our state. Third, the lion's share of the tax revenue too the state at 61% comes from property taxes. And finally, we get hit pretty hard for vehicle fees.

As I read over the comments from people reacting to the article it struck me how little most people seemed to understand how we stand versus the rest of the country as far as taxation is concerned.

First, we are one of the wealthiest in this country by income and also have one of the lowest tax burdens in the country. New Hampshire is nationally ranked at or near the bottom in terms of tax burden (state and local). Whether by total taxes raised in the state (44th lowest), per capita (around 46th lowest) or as a portion of the local GDP (47th lowest). Since propert tax is the only "broad-based" tax in the state, we rank in the top 5 for property tax burden - an easy target, but if you reduce that where do you make it up? In addition, New Hampshire ranks 7th highest in the nation in median income and around the 6th lowest in total taxes.

So how come people in NH seem to complain bitterly about how little they have? It's certainly possible that the income is distributed rather unevenly throughout the state so that the proportion of one's income that has to be used to pay property taxes varies wildly. But there also seems to be a pervasive perception that almost anything the state government takes is too much.

I think it would be more productive to start the conversation with questions such as, "What do you think the state as a whole should look like? What infrastructure do we need? What services do we need? How do we make paying for all of this as equitable as possible? How do you think not paying for the upkeep of roads will affect the safety of your travel? How do we get the most value out of the taxes we pay?" From my examination of the history of this state over the last couple of decades, there seems to be more interest in finding ways of shifting costs - pretending we don't really have them by moving them out of the debit column - than in addressing them. Health care costs too much? Shift costs from employers to employees. Not that employees should not be sharing the burden, but this has not reduced the cost of health care, it has simply reduced the effective salary paid to someone by removing that cost from the overhead paid by an employer. And reducing benefits will reduce costs, but will also have an effect on the ability of the employee to pay attention to work if they are worried about their family receiving appropriate care. These are connected issues and shifting costs does not fix anything, it is simply an attempt to sweep them under a rug so that shareholders don't see them.

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Knowledge Cartographer!

From the website Knowledge Cartography:

The aim of the research [on knowledge cartography] is to extend the cartographic metaphor beyond visual analogy, and to expose it as a narrative model and tool to intervene in complex, heterogeneous, dynamic realities, just like those of human geography. The map, in this context, is not only a passive representation of reality but a tool for the production of meaning. The map is thus a communication device: a mature representation artefact, aware of its own language and its own rhetoric, equipped with it its own tools, languages, techniques and supports. 


The part of this that fascinates me is that in my own attempts to understand the workings of systems that require the use of multi-level models to describe the relationships of the parts of the system to each other, I find myself creating my own internal maps to create an understandable relationship between those parts. Proximity is a measure of similarities between the parts of the system and the map is a narrative that gives the map contextual meaning. Not the narrative, of course, since another context or perspective could rearrange the parts in the map bases on another way of measuring similarities between the parts of the system. Then there are questions about how many dimensions can be represented - or rather how many dimensions have to be ignored or collapsed in order to place the visual map into a 2-D or 3-D representation. 


So if I have thought of myself as a novice knowledge engineer/explorer, now I can think of myself also as a knowledge cartographer. And I can see how this is connected to the work of Katy Börner, who has worked on the ways of visually representing scientific knowledge and who taught a half-day workshop I was privileged to attend a year or so ago.

Saturday, April 3, 2010

Feedback Loops in Healthcare Research

The subtitle for this could be "Healthcare Research as if People's Health Really Mattered".

  • I woke up this morning to my wife's coughing, wondering if it is "thrush" making a comeback.  Thrush is a fungal infection of her lungs that is a "side effect" of the medication she was taking during her Hep C treatment.  
  • Carrie also has a suppressed immune system that is the result of the chemotherapy she received for breast cancer treatment that makes her more susceptible to colds and infections from cuts.  
  • One other long-term effect (late effect) is the reduced cognitive function, again one of the "side effects" of chemotherapy.
So since I am so involved in cancer research as an informaticist I am aware of the various programs that are funded to understand and find therapies for cancer.  There are studies that are ongoing, but I wonder about the sense of urgency that is really in place.  There is such a focus on "finding the cure" for cancer that we forget the people who are "getting the cure".  What is the quality of life after such a cure?  This comes up for men and treatments for prostate cancer that leave them incontinent and with reduced sexual function.  They are thinking, "You call this a cure??  Sure, I'm alive, but I have to wear diapers and I can no longer even have, let alone enjoy, sex."  What would happen if people decided that they would rather be treated for the symptoms of the cancer with palliative care than be cured because they did not want to live with such a cure?

So I was thinking/wondering about what it is that drives our healthcare system in general terms.  Being in the US, the primary driver is really about making money.  Students go into med school and choose to be a specialist because there is more money in it.  Pharmaceutical companies invest huge sums of money into drug development because a blockbuster drug will repay the huge with vast sums of money.  The underlying theoretical framework driving these processes is the idea that the only way to really make progress -  in any field - is if commerce is in charge.

Rather than rejoice whenever a new hospital or medical research facility breaks ground we should weep and not rejoice.  It means that more money is being sunk into more "cures" and not in fixing the ones we already have.

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Confusion about community and social policy

It occurs to me, after all of the right-wing rhetoric about healthcare reform, that the right-wing of the Republican Party is getting confused about what community and social policy are about.  I don't know if it's the similarity between "community" and "communism" or between "social policy" and "socialism" that gets them tripped up.  If we are to live with each other, we need to find that balance between what/need I want and what you want/need without going into a rage or killing each other.  I know that my parents raised me to deal with that boundary in a civil manner, and even to find new insights into myself and the other person from the struggle with that boundary.  That is my microcosmic take on community.

For me social policy, or laws that pertain to something other than crime and punishment or defense of the community as a whole, comes out of an awareness that there is a balance to be found between me and my community.  Taxes fund projects I may find silly or disagree with, but I have my representatives who I write to about this and try to convince of my side.  But it is a debate and not a war.  If I lose it is not my life I am losing, it is just that I was unable to sway 51% of my group - be it town or county or state or country - to my way of thinking.  If I lose, it is not the end of civilization.  I think that tax policies in my state, New Hampshire, have gone way into dysfunctional, but I am not out raging at my fellow citizen who disagrees with me about how to fix it.

Take a chill pill and some time to reflect.  Stop watching 24-hour news and following blogs and reacting immediately to every tidbit.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Healthcare Reform

There have been just so many column inches, blogs and tweets committed to commenting on healthcare reform, but something I find missing in almost all is a sense of how all the parts that make up our healthcare system is an awareness that these parts do interact; they are not independent of each other.

The link for this posting is to an editorial in the local paper, the Valley News, that was attempting to summarize a series of interviews done by a local reporter, John Woodrow Cox. In an all too typical fashion, the editorial made no attempt to synthesize the six viewpoints presented by the six individuals who were interviewed. Cox himself said that the only constant between and among the stories was a lack of consistency. Well, you might just as well throw your hands up and say, "I give up! It's too hard and no one will ever agree!" This is unfortunately all too typical of the reporting we are seeing everywhere. Is it really that hard to get someone from The Dartmouth Institute who might be able to shed some light on this?

Monday, August 10, 2009

Letter to GOPUSA.com Owner and Editor

I've been getting the daily dose of headlines from a site that states that its goal is to remind the Republican Party of their conservative base. Other than an article that questioned Sarah Palin's decision to resign early from her governorship, for which he was roundly criticized, most of the articles are typical "red meat" for the conservative base. Here is a letter I wrote to the editor:

I guess from your bio that you are well set in your ways, adhering closely to dogma, so I don't believe any feedback I may give you will cause you to rethink anything to say or do. However, I'm an optimist at heart, so here goes.
The biggest change that I saw that Barack Obama brought was a deep knowledge that problems we have today do not have simple causes and their solutions cannot be achieved by one-dimensional and dogmatic thinking. President Bush saw the world as very black and white, good and evil, so the shift in approach was very refreshing.
I believe that both Democrats and Republicans suffer from the same kind of linear thinking that most people have, so it's no wonder that Obama is having a tough time with both sides of the aisle. What I don't really get is the value-add that you think your site provides to the dialogue and discussion, unless you are not really interested in having either. Highlighting extremes of behavior or isolated events and then attempting to infer/imply that these represent everything that a person or policy or group have to offer is just plain demagoguery and only serves to allow the most base of our human instincts to flourish - outrage, anger and contempt to name a few - and not the best aspects which include reason, humility and compassion.
I have done software development for large diverse groups for more that 15 years and from that experience I can say that the best solutions come from having all stakeholders at the table, all offering what they can to find a solution. I see that Obama has attempted many times to have Repuplicans be part of the decision-making processs, but instead of stepping up to do so they have instead chosen to remain on the sidelines, whining, griping and sniping. A solution to healthcare in this country is not going to work if it is Democrat or Republican. No one of us has a lock on the Truth. We can only discover what works by working together on all this. Having people at Town Halls yelling from the back of the rooms to shout over speakers is just bad form - my mother - and yours, I would hope - would disapprove of such brutish behavior. This is not a sign of general discontent being voiced, it is a sign of poor upbringing.

Sunday, August 9, 2009

Healthcare Reform and Linear Thinking

I've been listening to and reading responses from conservative Republicans to the Obama Administration's effort to reform the way health care is being performed and paid for in this country. I've frankly been astonished at the level of vitriol being issued by talking heads and bloggers on the right. You would think that Obama was one of the four horsemen of the Apocalypse and that as a result of health care reform we would all be forced to wait for hours in order to get substandard health care. Oh, wait, we already have that.

So, no it's that we will have some bureaucrat in Washington, DC deciding on whether or not we can get care. Oh, wait, we already have that...except my bureaucrat works for Aetna; but his or her role is the same: deciding on whether the care I get is appropriate or not.

So, no, it's that health care will become extraordinarily expensive if we make changes we will all be paying dearly just so everyone can get covered. Oh, wait, we already have that! Hospitals already have to charge insurance companies a premium over their actual cost since a certain percentage of their patients have no insurance or their insurance has been maxed out and so we do pay for the uninsured and under-insured. Plus a public hospital is legally bound to provide care to all, no matter if they can pay or not, so guess whose taxes pay for that?

There is a system that has grown around the payment for health care in this country that has constantly been pushed to shift costs from one group to another. As a result, in this country we have very little relationship between how much care costs and our health, as demonstrated in the Dartmouth Atlas project. So paying more does not give better care! How more non-linear can one get?

So how can we solve the issues surrounding health care reform? Not through the kind of dogma-driven arguments we have been seeing. Dogma has a very linear view of the world: there is my way (the right way) and any other way (the disastrously wrong way). Dogma is driven by belief systems not by data - just think of Galileo and the moons around Jupiter that could not exist in the Catholic Church's view of the world. Dogma is not interested in data that does not fit in to an established world-view since that data threatens the very stability of that world view.

Systems thinking relies on the kind of data that is provided by the above-mentioned Dartmouth Atlas project as well as many other Comparative Effectiveness studies. Systems and holarchical thinking value any kind of insight and data that does not fit into established ways of thinking since that is how we come to know more how a particular system works.

So a holarchical/systems view of health care looks at all aspects and contributing factors to one's health - genetics, lifestyle, family dynamics, community, socio-economic factors, environmental effects, access to care, employment, presence or lack of health insurance and one's spiritual life just to name a few - and how a health care system can be constructed to improve all our health. If we agree to put aside dogma and let data speak to us we can start the process of understanding how to move forward.